Skip to main content
English Home Latest About Us Editorial Team Bahasa Indonesia ID | EN

Sign in / Join

Explore

Home Latest Stories National International Business Education Opinion Bahasa Indonesia
Information
About JurnalPost Editorial Team Privacy Policy Media Kit
Sign in / Join
Follow us
ID ENGLISH
Home Latest National International Business Education Opinion

Latest

  1. Growing Up in the Digital Age: Is Early Childhood Brain Development Being Properly Stimulated?

  2. Forest Fires: When Law Enforcement Fails to Deter

  3. Hypersomnia: When You Get Enough Sleep but Still Feel Drowsy

  4. SIHATI 2026: UPN Veteran East Java Students and Kalijudan Seniors Paint Bags Together

  5. Eight Weeks of Internship at Harian Bhirawa: From the News Desk to Behind the Camera

  1. Home
  2. Opinion Column
  3. When AI Takes Over How Students Think

When AI Takes Over How Students Think

H
Writer: Habibah Shofah Harahap, S.Pd. | Mahasiswa S2 Manajemen Pendidikan dan Guru UPT SPF SMP Negeri 1 Batang Kuis
November 20, 2026, 15:17 WITA Editor: Danang Purnama
Nov 20, 2026, 15:17 WITA · 9 min read
9 min read
Habibah Shofah Harahap
Habibah Shofah Harahap

JurnalPost.com - Imagine a student copying a question into an artificial intelligence or Artificial Intelligence (AI) application. Within seconds, a neat, complete answer appears, along with the steps to solve it. The assignment is done, the grade is safe, and the teacher is satisfied. However, one important question is rarely asked: is the student actually learning, or are they simply moving an answer from a screen to a piece of paper?

The presence of AI in education offers various conveniences. This technology can help students understand material, find information, and complete assignments more quickly. However, behind this convenience lies an issue that requires serious attention.

The main problem with using AI in schools is not just whether the technology is permitted or not. A more fundamental issue arises when AI is used to replace the student's thinking process rather than support it, while the education system lacks adequate guidelines and oversight mechanisms.

From a Tool to a Replacement for the Thinking Process

In cognitive psychology, there is a term called cognitive offloading, which is the tendency for someone to delegate some mental tasks to an external tool or source.

To a certain extent, this habit is normal. Humans use calculators to compute, calendars to remember schedules, and search engines to find information.

However, the problem arises when the mental activities delegated to technology are actually core skills that should be developed through the learning process, such as reasoning, analyzing, evaluating information, and constructing arguments.

Gerlich (2025) conducted a study of 666 participants from various age groups and educational backgrounds through surveys and interviews. The study found a significant negative correlation between the frequency of AI use and critical thinking skills, with cognitive offloading as a mediating factor.

Younger participants tended to show higher dependence on AI and obtained lower critical thinking scores. Conversely, higher levels of education were associated with better critical thinking skills, regardless of the frequency of AI use.

Nevertheless, these findings must be understood with caution. The study used a correlational approach and therefore cannot prove that AI use directly causes a decline in critical thinking skills.

It is possible that individuals who already had weaker critical thinking habits were more prone to relying on AI.

Even so, these findings provide an important warning for the world of education, particularly regarding the use of AI by school-aged students and students in the early stages of higher education.

Experimental Evidence: How AI Use Determines Learning Outcomes

Other interesting findings come from a study by Bastani and colleagues (2025), which involved nearly one thousand high school students in Turkey in mathematics learning using GPT-4 technology.

The study compared several learning conditions: students who learned without AI assistance, students who used AI with an interface resembling standard ChatGPT (GPT Base), and students who used AI with a pedagogical approach (GPT Tutor).

GPT Tutor was designed to provide hints step-by-step, helping students understand the problem-solving process rather than immediately providing the final answer.

The results showed that students using AI were able to complete practice problems better while the technology was available.

However, when AI access was removed and students were asked to complete an exam independently, the group that used GPT Base scored about 17 percent lower than students who had learned without AI from the start.

These findings indicate that overly direct AI assistance has the potential to make students dependent on technology without truly understanding the concepts being learned.

Conversely, this negative impact was largely mitigated in the group that used GPT Tutor.

This study provides an important lesson that the educational issue is not just about choosing between using AI or not, but about determining how the technology is designed and utilized in learning.

However, the study's results have limitations as they were conducted on a single subject, within a specific timeframe, and in the educational context of one country. Therefore, its application in Indonesian schools still requires further research.

What is the Position of Indonesia's Education Policy?

In October 2024, the Ministry of Education, Culture, Research, and Technology issued Guidelines for the Use of Generative Artificial Intelligence in Higher Education Learning.

The presence of these guidelines is a positive step as it acknowledges both the opportunities and risks of using AI in education.

On one hand, generative AI can support personalized learning, increase efficiency, and assist in the development of learning resources. On the other hand, the technology also carries risks, including plagiarism, dependency, and the potential for declining creativity and critical thinking quality if used inappropriately.

The guidelines also encourage assessments that are not only oriented toward final results but also pay attention to the learning process through authentic assessment and project-based learning.

The problem is, as stated in the title, the guidelines are specifically intended for higher education.

Based on the author's search, no equivalent reference has been found that specifically regulates the use of generative AI at the primary and secondary education levels.

This condition is concerning because school-aged students are still in the stage of developing their thinking, reasoning, and independent learning skills.

Without clear guidelines, the regulation of AI use potentially depends on the policies of individual schools or the individual judgment of teachers.

Yet, the capabilities, experience, and readiness of educators in understanding AI technology are not always the same.

A Governance Issue, Not Just Student Behavior

Blaming students for using AI to complete assignments is not the right solution.

Students essentially respond to the prevailing assessment system. When learning success is measured more by correct answers, complete assignments, and neat final results, using AI to generate answers becomes a choice considered practical.

This problem shows that the education system needs to make adjustments.

If school assignments can be completed entirely by a machine without requiring student understanding, then what needs to be evaluated is not just the students' behavior, but also the learning design and assessment system.

From an educational management perspective, there are three main issues that need attention.

First, policies on AI use at the primary and secondary education levels need to be clarified so that schools have a reference that can be applied consistently.

Second, the assessment system needs to pay greater attention to the student's thinking process, not just the quality of the final product submitted.

Third, the capacity of teachers to understand and utilize AI must be strengthened through training relevant to learning needs.

These three aspects are interrelated. Good policies will not be effective without competent teachers, while competent teachers still require an assessment system capable of evaluating student skills authentically.

Recommendations for AI Use in Education

The use of AI in education should not be viewed as a threat to be avoided entirely. Instead, this technology needs to be managed so that it truly contributes to improving the quality of learning.

There are a number of steps that can be taken by various parties.

First, the government needs to draft guidelines for the use of generative AI for primary and secondary education.

These guidelines can adapt the principles developed in the 2024 higher education guidelines, with adjustments for the age, cognitive development, and needs of the students.

Regulations regarding usage limits, types of assignments, student data protection, and the principle of using AI as a learning companion need to receive attention.

The principle that AI functions to help students think, not replace their thinking process, also needs to be a consideration in the selection and procurement of learning platforms.

This is in line with the findings of Bastani and colleagues (2025), which show that the design of pedagogical support can influence student learning outcomes.

Second, educational units need to establish clear internal policies.

Schools can group AI use in learning activities into three categories: assignments that do not allow AI use, assignments that allow limited AI use, and assignments that allow AI use with the obligation to include a statement of its use.

This grouping can help students understand the limits of technology use while building an academic culture that is honest and responsible.

Schools also need to increase assessments that evaluate the learning process, such as drafting in stages, oral presentations, portfolios, discussions, and reflection notes.

Through this approach, teachers can know how students build understanding and develop arguments, not just see the final answer.

Third, teachers need to receive strengthening in competence and AI literacy.

It is not enough for teachers to just understand how to use AI applications. They also need to have the ability to design learning that encourages students to think independently.

For example, teachers can ask students to analyze answers generated by AI, find errors, test the accuracy of information, and compile improvements based on their own understanding.

This approach places AI as an object of critical analysis, not as a source of answers that is always considered correct.

Thus, teachers can utilize technological developments to strengthen higher-order thinking skills or higher-order thinking skills.

Fourth, higher education institutions and researchers need to expand research on AI use in Indonesian schools.

Small-scale experimental research can be conducted to determine how AI use affects critical thinking skills, independent learning, and student academic results.

The research also needs to consider differences in technology access, socioeconomic conditions, and the gap in educational facilities between regions.

Local research results are highly needed so that AI usage policies are not based solely on concerns or enthusiasm for technology, but on scientific evidence that is appropriate for the conditions of Indonesian education.

Maintaining Thinking Skills Amid Technological Progress

AI has become part of technological developments that affect the world of education. Its presence brings great opportunities to expand access to information, assist learning, and increase the efficiency of academic activities.

However, this convenience must not eliminate the fundamental goal of education, which is to form individuals who are capable of thinking independently, critically, creatively, and responsibly.

Students need to understand that a quick answer does not always reflect deep understanding. The ability to complete assignments with AI assistance also does not automatically show that someone has mastered the learning material.

Therefore, schools must ensure that AI use continues to provide space for students to ask questions, try, make mistakes, improve understanding, and build their own arguments.

Technology should strengthen human ability to think, not make humans lose the habit of thinking.

Ultimately, the biggest challenge for education in the AI era is not how to make students more proficient in using technology, but how to ensure they remain capable of learning and thinking independently when that technology is not available.

AI may help students find answers, but the process of understanding, questioning, and taking responsibility for those answers must remain with the student.


Bahasa Indonesia Read in Bahasa Indonesia →
  • #AI Taking Over
  • #AI Taking
  • #Taking Over How
  • #Taking Over
  • #Taking Over Thinking
  • #How Students Think
  • #How to Think
  • #Student Thinking
  • #This Technology

Share article

Share WhatsApp Tweet

Comments 0

Write a Comment Share your response

Comments appear after editorial approval.

  1. No comments yet. Be the first to respond.

Related Articles

Growing Up in the Digital Age: Is Early Childhood Brain Development Being Properly Stimulated?

Forest Fires: When Law Enforcement Fails to Deter

Non-ASN Teachers and Inpassing: When Long Service Does Not Always Mean Equality

The 2027 'Grade Retention' Nostalgia: Educational Panacea or Academic Punishment?

JURNALPOST RECOMMENDS

Selected for You

Out-of-Stock in Online Stores: A System Error or Planning Failure?

Hypersomnia: When You Get Enough Sleep but Still Feel Drowsy

When the Rupiah Requires Stronger Defenses

From Plastic Bottles to Rice Water: Ngageldadi Residents Embrace Circular Economy with UPN Veteran East Java

Article source: https://jurnalpost.com/en/when-ai-takes-over-how-students-think/98850/

Printed from JurnalPost.com on November 20, 2026, 16:04 WITA

Most Popular

  1. 1 UNTAG Surabaya Communication Student Gains Professional Experience Through Internship at RRI Madiun
  2. 2

    Revisiting Menstrual Leave: Between Presence and Absence

  3. 3

    Chaotic Campus Parking: A Discipline Issue or Poor Planning?

  4. 4

    UPN Veteran East Java Law Faculty Guides Kedungdowo Residents on Protecting Plant Varieties and Technological Innovations

  5. 5

    SDN 108 Ciumbuleuit Students Showcase Creativity at UNPAR PGSD Festival

JurnalPost

Independent reporting, public voices, and stories from Indonesia.

Explore

Advertorial Articles News Business Citizen Reporter Regional Economy English Version Essay Featured
Law International Opinion National Sports Education Politics Profiles Technology Travel

Information

About Us Citizen Journalism Cookie Policy Data Policy Submit an Opinion Submit an Article Media Kit Guidelines Editorial Team

Follow us

Facebook X/Twitter Instagram Threads TikTok Pinterest LinkedIn YouTube
© 2026 - PT Jurnal Post Indonesia. All Rights Reserved.