Skip to main content
English Home Latest About Us Editorial Team Bahasa Indonesia ID | EN

Sign in / Join

Explore

Home Latest Stories National International Business Education Opinion Bahasa Indonesia
Information
About JurnalPost Editorial Team Privacy Policy Media Kit
Sign in / Join
Follow us
ID ENGLISH
Home Latest National International Business Education Opinion

Latest

  1. Transforming Inclusive Early Childhood Education by 2026: Policy Mandates vs. Classroom Realities

  2. Protecting Childhood from Digital Screen Overload

  3. When Minor Symptoms Feel Like Serious Illness: Understanding Hypochondriasis

  4. Why Busy Businesses Still Lose Money: Balancing Promotion and Operational Efficiency

  5. World Tree Day 2026: Environmental Engineering Students Highlight Ecosystem Fragility Amid Forest Fires and the Need for Mitigation

  1. Home
  2. Opinion Column
  3. Out-of-Stock in Online Stores: A System Error or Planning Failure?

Out-of-Stock in Online Stores: A System Error or Planning Failure?

N
Writer: Nabillah Eka Damayanti | Mahasiswa Manajemen Keuangan, Fakultas Ekonomi dan Bisnis, Universitas Pamulang
November 19, 2026, 18:35 WITA Editor: Shella Paramitha
Nov 19, 2026, 18:35 WITA · 6 min read
6 min read
original photo
Conceptual illustration: A comparison of demand spikes during promotions with inventory based on estimation versus inventory supported by safety stock. Data is simulated. Source: Infographic compiled by the author based on Kusuma & Nuha (2003).

JurnalPost.com - The “out of stock” label on a desired item is a familiar sight for online shoppers. This condition is often immediately attributed to a system error. However, such accusations may mask more fundamental issues in Operations and Production Management, particularly regarding inventory planning and control.


Technology Can Indeed Be Flawed

Technology can certainly be a cause of inventory issues. Delayed stock data updates on an application or discrepancies with actual warehouse conditions can lead to information mismatches between sellers and buyers.

However, it must be understood that systems essentially only display data entered and managed by humans. The accuracy of these inventory figures depends heavily on stock management decisions made long before a buyer clicks the purchase button.

Thus, the problem of out-of-stock items cannot always be solved simply by fixing an application or updating a system.

Out-of-Stock Is Not a New Problem

The issue of inventory depletion has long been a concern in the retail world.

Cross-country research on product availability in physical retail, particularly for fast-moving consumer goods, shows that stockouts are a recurring problem with little sign of improvement.

The research identifies the supply chain as a source of the problem, while management at the store level is a crucial part of the solution. It also notes the tendency of consumers to switch to other stores when the desired item is unavailable, with the potential of not returning (Corsten & Gruen, 2003).

promo
Ilustrasi: Penjual daring mengecek rak yang mulai kosong sambil memantau data penjualan melalui laptop. Sumber: Ilustrasi vektor orisinal yang dibuat khusus untuk artikel ini.

In my view, these findings are increasingly relevant in online commerce. If consumers previously had to physically move to find items in other stores, they now only need a few taps to find alternative sellers.

The Root Cause Lies in Planning

In Operations and Production Management, inventory planning plays a vital role in maintaining the balance between demand and product availability.

Demand forecasting that is too low can lead to stock shortages, while estimates that are too high risk causing inventory accumulation.

Inventory control that relies solely on experience or estimates without calculating safety stock also increases the risk of running out of items when demand rises (Kusuma & Nuha, 2026).

Similar issues were found in research on drug inventory control at Damhil Pharmacy, Gorontalo. Suboptimal inventory management led to stock levels that sometimes exceeded needs, but at other times failed to meet demand. This situation potentially causes customers to switch and reduces business profits (Padiku et al., 2023).

Meanwhile, research on restaurants serving both offline and online channels shows the challenge of demand fluctuations from both channels.

Inventory control that still relies on observation, without safety stock, service levels, or measurable inventory targets, is an issue that needs improvement (Kusuma & Nuha, 2026).

Big Promotions Are a Forecasting Test

In my opinion, the surge in orders during double-date promotions or national shopping days is one of the greatest tests of a seller's ability to forecast demand.

Sellers who rely only on memory or estimates based on the previous year's sales risk experiencing two conditions simultaneously: running out of the most popular items and accumulating products that are less in demand.

fafff
Ilustrasi: Alur pengendalian persediaan sederhana bagi penjual daring, mulai dari pencatatan penjualan, peramalan permintaan, hingga penentuan stok pengaman. Sumber: Infografis disusun penulis berdasarkan Padiku dkk. (2023) dan Kusuma & Nuha (2026).

This situation shows that increased transactions do not always go hand-in-hand with successful inventory management.

Technology as an Assistant, Not a Suspect

Technology remains important, especially for sellers marketing products through multiple marketplaces simultaneously.

Cross-channel inventory synchronization systems can help prevent an item from being sold twice due to conflicting stock information.

However, technology should be viewed as a decision-support tool, not a substitute for planning.

Even sophisticated systems will not fully resolve issues if decisions regarding inventory levels, reorder points, and demand forecasts are still made without adequate calculation.

In other words, technology can accelerate the execution of correct decisions, but it does not automatically fix flawed stock management decisions.

Steps Sellers Can Take

Small-scale online sellers can actually start inventory control through three simple steps.

First, record daily sales by product type and sales channel. This recording is necessary so that sellers understand the demand pattern for each item.

Second, forecast demand using the moving average method from several previous periods. This method can help sellers make forecasts based on data, not just intuition.

Third, provide safety stock, especially for products with high demand levels or those requiring relatively long procurement times (Padiku et al., 2023; Kusuma & Nuha, 2026).


These three steps can be complemented by periodic inventory reviews, for example every seven days, then placing orders based on the difference between the inventory target and the stock still available.

This periodic review approach is also proposed in research on inventory control for restaurants with a dual-channel sales system (Kusuma & Nuha, 2026).

For products with long procurement times, a pre-order system pre-order can be an alternative so that sellers have an overview of product needs before procurement.

Additionally, sellers should not rely solely on successful transaction data.

Unmet demand also needs to be monitored, for example through the number of visits to an out-of-stock product page or a list of potential buyers requesting notifications when stock is back.

This information can help sellers understand the gap between the number of items successfully sold and the actual potential demand when the product is unavailable.

Prepare Goods Before Buyers Arrive

Out-of-stock items in online stores are sometimes caused by system errors. However, in my opinion, these issues often reflect immature inventory planning.

Successful stock management does not depend only on technological sophistication, but also on the accuracy of forecasting, the availability of safety stock, and discipline in reading sales data.

Ultimately, the superior store is not the one that hoards the most goods or is the fastest to display an “out of stock” label, but the one capable of estimating needs and preparing products before buyers arrive.

Bibliography

Corsten, D., & Gruen, T. (2003). Desperately seeking shelf availability: An examination of the extent, the causes, and the efforts to address retail out-of-stocks. International Journal of Retail & Distribution Management, 31(12), 605–617. https://doi.org/10.1108/09590550310507731

Kusuma, H. C., & Nuha, H. (2026). Analysis of perishable raw material inventory control in a dual-channel supply chain system using the periodic review system method (Case study: Mie Paus Restaurant). Populer: Student Research Journal, 5(2), 198–211. https://doi.org/10.58192/populer.v5i2.4552

Padiku, I. R., Hadjaratie, L., Papeo, D. R. P., & Walahe, M. F. F. (2023). Application of WMA and EOQ methods in the drug stock inventory control information system at Damhil Pharmacy. Technical Journal, 21(2), 155–167. https://doi.org/10.37031/jt.v21i2,419

Bahasa Indonesia Read in Bahasa Indonesia →
  • #Operations Management
  • #Out-of-Stock
  • #Online Store
  • #Inventory Control
  • #Demand Forecasting

Share article

Share WhatsApp Tweet

Comments 0

Write a Comment Share your response

Comments appear after editorial approval.

  1. No comments yet. Be the first to respond.

Related Articles

Protecting Childhood from Digital Screen Overload

World Tree Day 2026: Environmental Engineering Students Highlight Ecosystem Fragility Amid Forest Fires and the Need for Mitigation

Maintaining Product Quality in the Modern Industrial Era: Production Strategies to Boost Competitiveness

Growing Up in the Digital Age: Is Early Childhood Brain Development Being Properly Stimulated?

JURNALPOST RECOMMENDS

Selected for You

The Role of Digital Marketing and Content Creativity in Developing Automotive Services at DB AUTOLIGHT

Transforming Inclusive Early Childhood Education by 2026: Policy Mandates vs. Classroom Realities

Schizophrenia Is Not Multiple Personality Disorder: Understanding Symptoms, Causes, and Treatment

Hypersomnia: When You Get Enough Sleep but Still Feel Drowsy

Article source: https://jurnalpost.com/en/out-of-stock-online-stores-system-error-planning-failure/98823/

Printed from JurnalPost.com on November 20, 2026, 22:09 WITA

Most Popular

  1. 1 UNTAG Surabaya Communication Student Gains Professional Experience Through Internship at RRI Madiun
  2. 2

    Revisiting Menstrual Leave: Between Presence and Absence

  3. 3

    Chaotic Campus Parking: A Discipline Issue or Poor Planning?

  4. 4

    UPN Veteran East Java Law Faculty Guides Kedungdowo Residents on Protecting Plant Varieties and Technological Innovations

  5. 5

    SDN 108 Ciumbuleuit Students Showcase Creativity at UNPAR PGSD Festival

JurnalPost

Independent reporting, public voices, and stories from Indonesia.

Explore

Advertorial Articles News Business Citizen Reporter Regional Economy English Version Essay Featured
Law International Opinion National Sports Education Politics Profiles Technology Travel

Information

About Us Citizen Journalism Cookie Policy Data Policy Submit an Opinion Submit an Article Media Kit Guidelines Editorial Team

Follow us

Facebook X/Twitter Instagram Threads TikTok Pinterest LinkedIn YouTube
© 2026 - PT Jurnal Post Indonesia. All Rights Reserved.