By: Zhora Chelsea Agatha, a student at the Faculty of Law, Universitas Muhammadiyah Malang
Higher education institutions are spaces where students develop critical thinking skills, build knowledge, and cultivate intellectual responsibility. One manifestation of this responsibility is the completion of academic work, including the undergraduate thesis, which serves as a requirement for obtaining an academic degree. However, these educational goals face significant challenges as the practices of thesis brokering and plagiarism persist within university environments.
The practice of thesis brokering is no longer a trivial issue. According to the Education Integrity Assessment Survey (SPI) 2026 conducted by the Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK), the practice of students paying third parties to complete final assignments or theses was found in 91 percent of the higher education institutions surveyed. Furthermore, 43 percent of higher education respondents reported the existence of such practices. These findings indicate that academic integrity remains a serious challenge in the education sector. The survey results were presented during the launch of the Education Integrity Index 2026 in Jakarta on 6 October 2026.
This phenomenon warrants attention because academic work should reflect a student's own abilities and original thought. A thesis is not merely an administrative requirement for a degree; it is a vital part of the learning process that trains students in research, analysis, and argumentation. When this process is outsourced to others, the intended educational objectives remain unfulfilled.
Various conditions can drive students to take shortcuts, such as pressure to graduate quickly, time constraints, difficulties in understanding research methods, and a lack of proficiency in academic writing. Conversely, the availability of brokers offering to complete assignments for a fee makes these practices increasingly accessible. Nevertheless, academic difficulty cannot justify delegating the responsibility of producing academic work to others.
From a legal perspective, the issue of thesis brokering and plagiarism relates to academic integrity and compliance with university regulations. Ministry of Education, Culture, Research, and Technology Regulation Number 39 of 2021 on Academic Integrity in Producing Academic Work governs various forms of academic integrity violations, including plagiarism and unauthorized authorship. Submitting work prepared by others as one's own contradicts the principles of honesty and academic responsibility. Therefore, this issue must be addressed through examination mechanisms and academic sanctions in accordance with applicable regulations.
The impact of these practices is felt not only by the students who cheat but also by educational institutions and society at large. An academic degree should serve as recognition that an individual has undergone a learning process and met specific competencies. If that process is bypassed through the help of a broker, the quality and credibility of the degree become questionable. Moreover, university graduates will eventually enter the workforce and assume responsibilities within their fields. In law, for instance, the ability to analyze problems, understand regulations, and construct arguments is a crucial skill that cannot be replaced by a mere degree.
Addressing this issue should not focus solely on imposing sanctions on students. Universities must evaluate their mentorship and academic supervision systems. Students experiencing difficulties in writing academic work require adequate guidance, from selecting research topics to completing the thesis. Furthermore, oversight of the research process must be strengthened so that evaluation is not oriented solely toward the final result, but also considers the process of its creation. The application of academic sanctions must also be carried out fairly and consistently so that regulations do not become mere formalities.
On the other hand, students must understand that academic honesty is part of their responsibility as learners. Using a broker might seem like a quick way to fulfill academic obligations, but such actions deprive them of the opportunity to develop their own capabilities. An academic culture that upholds honesty must be built through student awareness, the exemplary conduct of lecturers, and the consistent application of rules.
Ultimately, the success of higher education should not be measured solely by the number of graduates or the speed at which one obtains a degree. The core value of education lies in the ability, honesty, and responsibility built during the learning process. Thesis brokering and plagiarism must be viewed as serious issues because they undermine academic integrity. An academic degree should be a recognition of an individual's competence, not merely the result of a transaction.
References
- Devi Puspitasari. (6 October 2026). “KPK Integrity Survey: Thesis Brokering Occurs in 91% of Campuses.” detikNews. Read source
- Ministry of Higher Education, Science, and Technology. (6 October 2026). “Education Integrity Score 2026 Rises to 73.30, Classified as Adaptive.” Read source
- Ministry of Education, Culture, Research, and Technology Regulation Number 39 of 2021 on Academic Integrity in Producing Academic Work. Read source
About the Author
Zhora Chelsea Agatha is a student at the Faculty of Law, Universitas Muhammadiyah Malang, with an interest in legal issues, education, and social problems. Through her opinion pieces, she aims to convey critical views on various societal issues from a legal perspective.
Comments 0
Write a Comment Share your response