By: Sugianto, S.H., M.H.
Doctor of Law, Islamic University of Bandung
The evolution of information technology has fundamentally altered societal life, particularly in sectors such as the economy, governance, communication, and public services. The ubiquity of digital technology has rendered personal data a critical component of modern existence. Information such as residency records, financial data, addresses, biometric identifiers, and digital activity logs are no longer viewed merely as administrative details; they now possess significant economic, social, and legal value. This reality presents a serious challenge regarding the extent to which the government and electronic system providers may access and utilize an individual's personal data without infringing upon their constitutional rights.
Incidents of data breaches and unauthorized use of personal information highlight a persistent gap between technological advancement and the adequacy of legal protections. Indonesia has enacted Law Number 27 of 2022 concerning Personal Data Protection as a legal instrument to safeguard the rights of data subjects. However, the existence of these regulations has not fully resolved implementation issues, particularly regarding oversight, the accountability of data controllers, and the effective restoration of public rights. To date, the establishment of a dedicated personal data protection authority remains a focal point in national policy discourse. From the perspective of legal philosophy, this issue cannot be adequately addressed solely through a normative approach that merely questions compliance with legislation. An axiological approach is required to evaluate the values, objectives, and benefits that the law seeks to achieve. Therefore, personal data protection must be regarded as essential to upholding human dignity, justice, utility, and government accountability within a democratic legal system.
Discussion
Axiology is the branch of philosophy that examines the nature and meaning of values, including ethical values and the utility of knowledge. In the context of digital technology, axiology does not merely question how technology functions, but also explores the purpose of its application and whether its impact provides equitable benefits to humanity. Consequently, the success of digital transformation should not be measured solely by economic efficiency and technological progress, but also by its capacity to protect human rights and dignity.
First, according to the principle of justice, data privacy must be recognized as a fundamental human right. Every individual holds an equal position in receiving protection for their personal information. If a data breach occurs due to the negligence of a data controller, legal liability must not be shifted onto the public, who are the rightful owners of the data.
Second, in terms of utility, the use of personal data is essential for improving public services, facilitating digital transactions, and fostering technological development. However, these benefits cannot serve as a justification for the excessive collection or exploitation of data.
Third, according to moral values, personal data protection requires honesty and accountability from every party handling public information. Consent from data subjects should not be treated as a mere administrative formality but must be grounded in a sufficient understanding of the purpose and consequences of data processing.
In the author's view, these issues demonstrate that the greatest challenge in protecting data privacy lies not only in the lack of legal regulations but also in the disconnect between those regulations, institutional practices, and underlying moral values. Therefore, a more integrated legal approach is necessary—one that combines clear legal mandates, the duties and responsibilities of electronic system providers, and the value of justice as the primary objective of legal protection. This approach is vital to ensure that the law functions not merely as an administrative tool, but as a genuine safeguard for human interests.
Conclusion
From an axiological perspective, personal data protection is a critical issue tied to values of justice, utility, morality, and respect for human dignity. Law Number 27 of 2022 concerning Personal Data Protection provides a legal foundation for safeguarding public rights. However, its effectiveness must be bolstered by stricter oversight, robust institutional systems, firm law enforcement, and clear ethical responsibilities for data controllers. Ultimately, the law must ensure that humanity remains the primary beneficiary of technological development, rather than being treated merely as a source of data. The state, electronic system providers, and the public must recognize that safeguarding personal data is a collective responsibility. The success of legal development in the digital age will be measured not only by the ability to produce technological innovations but by the capacity to ensure those innovations align with principles of justice, humanity, and legal certainty.
References
- Yusman, Y., Putra, R. R., & Sinaga, I. (2024). Application of information systems to improve governance and public services in the digital era. Serasi Media Teknologi.
- Herman, P. Y., Karneli, Y., & Handayani, P. G. (2025). A descriptive study on ontology, epistemology, and axiology in the philosophy of science. Socius: Journal of Social Science Research, 2(11).
- Huda, H. U. N., SH, M., Astaruddin, H. T., SH, M. S., Nasution, M. I., SH, M., ... & SH, M. (2024). Personal data, citizen rights, and the rule of law: Protecting privacy amidst digital threats. Widina Publisher.
- Disemadi, H. S., Sudirman, L., Girsang, J., & Aninda, A. M. (2023). Personal data protection in the digital era: Why should we care?. Sang Sewagati Journal, 1(2), 66-90.
- Ardiana Hidayah, S. H. (2025). Personal Data Protection in the Digital Era. Inovasi Publishing Indonesia.
Comments 0
Write a Comment Share your response