Loneliness, it turns out, does not require an empty room. There is a type of loneliness that does not arise when we are alone, but rather when we are sitting at a table full of laughter, surrounded by people we know.
This may sound strange, but loneliness is not always related to the presence of others. Yanguas et al. (2018) explain that a person can be alone and not feel alone and vice versa. This means that the number of people around us does not always determine how connected we feel to them. Instead, there is a gap between our expectations and the relationships we truly experience. This phenomenon is not limited to a small group of people. Killeen (1998) refers to loneliness as an “epidemic” in modern society, something that, to some degree, almost everyone experiences.
But if it is not about the number of people, then what is it about? To address this, this article will use two philosophical perspectives: Hannah Arendt, who distinguishes between solitude and loneliness, and Martin Heidegger, who discusses how we can become so immersed in the “they” that we forget how to be ourselves.
Arendt’s View: Being Alone Is Not the Same as Loneliness
Hannah Arendt distinguishes between two states that appear similar at a glance: solitude and loneliness. Solitude is a state where we are alone but do not feel empty because we are still “accompanied” by ourselves. Like walking alone while reflecting, there is a conversation in our heads that keeps us feeling whole. Arendt describes this as a “two-in-one” state, where a person is with themselves. Conversely, loneliness is when we feel abandoned by everyone, even losing our connection with ourselves (Arendt, 1962).
This distinction shows that being alone is not always a negative experience. One can enjoy time alone without feeling lonely. Conversely, one can be in the middle of a crowd but still feel disconnected from everyone. For example, when we are sitting with friends and joining in the laughter during a conversation, but actually feel that no one truly understands what we are thinking or feeling.
Arendt also explains that loneliness is most visible when a person is among others. This happens because the presence of people around us does not always create a meaningful connection. In fact, a person can lose their connection with themselves when they no longer have the space to dialogue and understand who they are. In this view, loneliness is not just about the absence of others, but also about the loss of connection with the self (Costache, 2013).
Thus, what distinguishes solitude from loneliness is not the presence or absence of others, but how a person experiences their relationship with themselves and the world around them.
Heidegger’s View: Following the Current, Forgetting the Self
Martin Heidegger has a way of explaining why we can be in a crowd but not feel like ourselves. According to him, the world we understand is influenced by shared goals, norms, and tastes. Therefore, in many ways, we act as “anyone” would act. Heidegger calls this das Man, or the “they” (Heidegger, 1962).
Examples are easy to find in daily life. We follow current trends, whether in fashion, music, or conversation topics, just to feel like we “fit in.” Over time, we no longer question whether we actually like these things, or if we are just doing them because everyone else is.
Actually, Heidegger does not consider living with others to be a bad thing. Human existence is always related to others. Relationships such as being a friend, child, parent, or part of a group help shape how a person understands themselves and the world. However, the problem arises when a person becomes too immersed in habits and general standards to the point where they no longer question whether the choices they make truly come from themselves.
Heidegger does not directly discuss that following societal habits can cause loneliness. However, the concept of das Man can be used as a perspective to understand that possibility. When a person constantly conforms to be accepted, they may drift further away from what they actually think, feel, or desire. Ultimately, even though they are physically present with others, it does not necessarily mean they are truly present as themselves.
Two Perspectives, One Paradox
If these two lines of thought are combined, the picture becomes clearer. Arendt shows what is lost when we are lonely: our own selves. Heidegger provides a clue as to how this can happen in a crowd: when we are too immersed in the pattern of “being like everyone else.” That is why the presence of many people does not automatically cure loneliness. What we long for is not just to be accompanied, but to be truly encountered as our authentic selves.
Arendt reminds us that we need two things simultaneously: time with ourselves and the presence of others. Neither can replace the other. A crowd without a present self feels empty, and a whole self still needs others.
Therefore, loneliness in a crowd is not a sign that something is wrong with us. It is more like a signal that there is a connection with ourselves or with others that we are longing for.
Returning to that table full of laughter: the laughter may be real, and the people may be sincere. But only one question remains. In the midst of all that, have we truly been present as ourselves? And is there someone who has encountered us there?
Comments 0
Write a Comment Share your response