Skip to main content
English Home Latest About Us Editorial Team Bahasa Indonesia ID | EN

Sign in / Join

Explore

Home Latest Stories National International Business Education Opinion Bahasa Indonesia
Information
About JurnalPost Editorial Team Privacy Policy Media Kit
Sign in / Join
Follow us
ID ENGLISH
Home Latest National International Business Education Opinion

Latest

  1. Untag Surabaya Communications Student Boosts Cafe VOC Social Media Presence During Internship

  2. Forced to Grow Up: Why Students Drop Out of School

  3. How Communication Students Optimize Branding for Studio Gitafoto

  4. UNTAG Surabaya Communication Student Gains Professional Experience Through Internship at RRI Madiun

  5. Counseling Spaces for Self-Discovery and Future Planning

  1. Home
  2. Articles
  3. Living to Work? Analyzing Indonesia's Labor Landscape Through Marx and Han

Living to Work? Analyzing Indonesia's Labor Landscape Through Marx and Han

S
Writer: shaFa rasyidah
November 17, 2026, 08:53 WITA Editor: Rina Maharani
Nov 17, 2026, 08:53 WITA · 7 min read
7 min read
An illustration depicting exhaustion caused by overwork.
An illustration depicting exhaustion caused by overwork. Photo: Tara Winstead / Pexels

JAKARTA, JurnalPost.com - Work is intended to be a means for humans to build a better life. Through employment, individuals earn an income, develop their skills, and find their place in society. However, what happens when work gradually takes over almost every aspect of life?

This phenomenon is becoming increasingly familiar in modern daily life. Overtime is often seen as a sign of loyalty, a packed schedule is viewed as a symbol of success, and taking time to rest can sometimes trigger feelings of guilt.

IKLAN

The question is: do people still work to enjoy life, or are they sacrificing their lives to keep working?

[Insert illustration of exhaustion due to overwork here]

This issue is not merely a debate about time management. There are economic conditions and social pressures that make individuals feel they must remain productive, even when their bodies and minds require rest.

In a study cited from Nugroho, Hidayat, and Sulistyaningrum (2026), more than a quarter of Indonesian workers are reported to work beyond 48 hours per week. The study also notes that the median income of workers is approximately 40 percent below the minimum wage, while about 58 percent of workers are in the informal sector.

This picture shows that working longer hours does not always mean someone is chasing success. For some, additional working hours are simply a way to meet basic living needs.

This phenomenon can be understood through the thoughts of two philosophers from different eras: Karl Marx and Byung-Chul Han.

Karl Marx and the Worker Who Lost Control

Karl Marx viewed work as one of the primary ways for humans to express their abilities and creativity.

Through work, an individual should be able to create something meaningful while simultaneously developing themselves.

However, in a capitalist system, the relationship between humans and their work can change. Workers sell their labor to earn wages, while the results of production and the profits remain primarily under the control of capital owners.

Marx explained this state through the concept of alienation .

In his thoughts on alienated labor in 1844, Marx identified four forms of alienation.

First, the worker is alienated from the product of their labor because what is produced belongs to someone else.

Second, the worker loses control over the work process. Time, methods, and work targets are determined more by the system than by personal will.

Third, work can alienate humans from themselves. Activities that should be a means of developing potential turn into a routine for mere survival.

Fourth, workers can be alienated from their peers as human relationships become increasingly dominated by competition.

These thoughts remain relevant in modern life.

Someone might work from morning until night but still struggle to meet basic needs. Others must take on additional jobs because their primary income is insufficient.

In such conditions, long working hours are not entirely a free choice, but a consequence of economic pressure.

Byung-Chul Han: When Humans Exploit Themselves

If Marx explained the pressure arising from economic structures, Byung-Chul Han offers a different perspective.

The South Korean-born philosopher, who works in Germany, discusses the transformation of modern society into what he calls the achievement society.

In Han's view, society is no longer driven solely by orders, prohibitions, and obligations from external parties.

Pressure now arises from the belief that everyone must be capable of developing, achieving, and continuously increasing their productivity.

One does not always need a boss ordering overtime. An individual might choose to keep working because they feel they have not done enough.

This is what Han calls self-exploitation.

Humans become both the party demanding and the party bearing those demands.

This phenomenon is easily found in daily life.

Workers continue to check office messages at night. Weekends are used to finish extra work. Even during holidays, one might feel uncomfortable because of the nagging thought that there is something that should be done.

IKLAN

Digital technology further complicates the situation. Messaging apps and work devices ensure that professional matters can reach an individual at any time.

The boundary between work time and personal life is becoming increasingly blurred.

At a certain point, the pressure to always be productive can increase the risk of prolonged exhaustion and burnout.

Are We Truly Free to Choose to Keep Working?

An interesting issue arises when someone considers long working hours to be their own choice.

Does the decision to keep working automatically demonstrate freedom?

The thoughts of Marx and Han can actually complement each other in answering this question.

Marx reminds us that freedom is not sufficiently measured by one's right to accept or reject work.

Workers may legally be able to refuse overtime or resign. However, when their income is the only source for meeting a family's needs, that choice is not always realistic.

Freedom written in regulations is not necessarily the same as the freedom that can truly be exercised.

Meanwhile, Han reminds us that pressure does not always stem from economic conditions.

Even people with adequate incomes can continue to force themselves to work because they link busyness with self-worth and success.

In such a situation, someone might have the opportunity to rest but feels like a failure when not doing something productive.

Nevertheless, Han's thoughts should not be used to blame workers who experience exhaustion.

Not everyone works excessively due to personal ambition. Some must do so because of unavoidable economic demands.

That is why the issue of work needs to be viewed from two sides simultaneously: the socio-economic structure and the psychological pressures developing in society.

Restoring the Meaning of Work in Life

The discussions of Marx and Han bring us to a fundamental question: how do we restore work as a part of human life, rather than something that dominates our entire existence?

From Marx's perspective, improving working conditions is essential.

Humane working hours, decent wages, labor protection, and respect for the right to rest are all part of efforts to build a healthier working relationship.

Workers also need space to voice their opinions and participate in decisions that affect their professional lives.

Meanwhile, Han's thinking invites society to question the metrics of success that have long been considered normal.

Must one always be busy to be seen as successful?

Does resting mean losing the opportunity to advance?

And can human value truly be measured by how much work one is able to complete?

These questions are important because productivity does not inherently have to conflict with quality of life.

Working hard is certainly not wrong. There are times when work requires greater attention and effort. However, the problem arises when those demands continue indefinitely without room for recovery.

Ultimately, the measure of success should not be seen only through job titles, income, or the amount of work completed.

Time with family, health, social relationships, and the opportunity to enjoy life also hold no less importance.

Because work should help humans lead a meaningful life.

We work to live, not to spend our entire lives just working.

Bahasa Indonesia Read in Bahasa Indonesia →
  • #Economy
  • #World of Work
  • #Philosophy
  • #Byung-Chul Han
  • #Quality of Life
  • #Economic Pressure
  • #Karl Marx
  • #Working Hours
  • #Achievement Society

Share article

Share WhatsApp Tweet

Comments 0

Write a Comment Share your response

Comments appear after editorial approval.

  1. No comments yet. Be the first to respond.

Related Articles

How Communication Students Optimize Branding for Studio Gitafoto

Loneliness in a Crowd: Losing Yourself in Social Connections

Who is Amelia in Juna Animation? Fan Theories on the Purple Star-Eyed Character

Neglected Public Facilities: Where Does Management Responsibility Lie?

JURNALPOST RECOMMENDS

Selected for You

Over 1,000 Students Participate in SMP Labschool Cibubur’s LASER XV

University of Indonesia's 'Diversity Hero' Team Promotes Tolerance Culture in Cibunian Village

PPSDM Migas Hosts Oil and Gas Technical Head Certification Training in Cepu

Counseling Spaces for Self-Discovery and Future Planning

Article source: https://jurnalpost.com/en/living-to-work-analyzing-indonesias-labor-landscape-through-marx-and-han/98737/

Printed from JurnalPost.com on November 17, 2026, 09:17 WITA

Most Popular

  1. 1 Revisiting Menstrual Leave: Between Presence and Absence
  2. 2

    Chaotic Campus Parking: A Discipline Issue or Poor Planning?

  3. 3

    UPN Veteran East Java Law Faculty Guides Kedungdowo Residents on Protecting Plant Varieties and Technological Innovations

  4. 4

    SDN 108 Ciumbuleuit Students Showcase Creativity at UNPAR PGSD Festival

  5. 5

    Indonesia Falls to Myanmar in CAEC MLBB 2026 Final, RRQ Hoshi Takes Runner-Up

IKLAN
JurnalPost

Independent reporting, public voices, and stories from Indonesia.

Explore

Advertorial Articles News Business Citizen Reporter Regional Economy English Version Essay Featured
Law International Opinion National Sports Education Politics Profiles Technology Travel

Information

About Us Citizen Journalism Cookie Policy Data Policy Submit an Opinion Submit an Article Media Kit Guidelines Editorial Team

Follow us

Facebook X/Twitter Instagram Threads TikTok Pinterest LinkedIn YouTube
© 2026 - PT Jurnal Post Indonesia. All Rights Reserved.