JurnalPost.com - Social concern is a form of human attention toward the circumstances and needs of others. In daily life, this care is manifested through simple actions, such as helping those in difficulty, sharing with the needy, or considering the interests of others before making decisions.
On the other hand, every human also has a need to survive and fulfill their own interests. These two impulses raise a fundamental question: are humans inherently self-centered, or do they possess a natural tendency to care for others?
An interesting event occurred in May 2020 in Sirau Village, Kemranjen District, Banyumas Regency. A total of 12 residents reportedly returned their Direct Cash Assistance (BLT) because they felt there were others in the community who were more in need of the aid (Anugrah, 2020).
This decision is worth examining. Amidst the difficult economic conditions caused by the COVID-19 pandemic, they chose to provide an opportunity for others deemed more in need.
This event invites us to re-examine the fundamental nature of humanity. Do humans always prioritize personal interests, or are they actually capable of setting aside their own needs for the well-being of others?
This question can be explored through the thoughts of two great philosophers, Thomas Hobbes and Jean-Jacques Rousseau. Both hold different views on human nature, particularly regarding the relationship between personal interest, social life, and concern for others.
Thomas Hobbes: Humans and the Drive for Self-Preservation
In the thought of Thomas Hobbes, humans have a fundamental drive to survive and fulfill their needs. Through his work Leviathan (1651), Hobbes explains that humans strive to obtain things they consider essential for their survival.
Problems arise when individual interests clash while available resources are limited. This state can trigger competition, suspicion, and even conflict between humans.
In this context, personal interest becomes a significant factor influencing an individual's actions.
When linked to social assistance, Hobbes's thought helps explain why individuals strive to obtain aid when facing economic difficulties.
The desire to receive aid does not necessarily indicate selfishness. Every person in need has the right to pursue assistance in accordance with applicable regulations.
However, the issue becomes different when someone intentionally provides information that does not match their economic reality to continue receiving aid, even though they do not meet the criteria for recipients.
In such circumstances, personal interest has the potential to harm others who are more in need.
Hobbes also emphasizes the importance of rules and agreements in communal life. When every individual pursues their own interests without considering the interests of others, conflict becomes easier to trigger.
Therefore, rules are needed to control the clash of interests and create a more orderly social life.
In the distribution of social assistance, this thought is relevant to the importance of clear recipient criteria, accurate data collection, and accountable distribution mechanisms.
Thus, justice does not rely solely on individual awareness to prioritize others. The government also has a responsibility to ensure that aid is received by those who are truly entitled to it.
Jean-Jacques Rousseau: Compassion as Part of Human Nature
Unlike Hobbes, Jean-Jacques Rousseau emphasizes the human capacity to feel compassion for the suffering of others.
In his work, Discours sur l’origine et les fondements de l’inégalité parmi les hommes (1755), Rousseau explains that humans possess not only the drive for self-preservation but also a natural capacity to feel the suffering of other beings.
This tendency is explained through the concept of pitié, which is the feeling of pity or compassion that arises when someone witnesses the suffering of others.
Rousseau also introduced the concept of amour de soi, which is the natural love for oneself related to the effort to maintain life and fulfill basic needs.
This concept differs from amour-propre, which is the self-love that develops through social relationships, especially when humans begin to compare themselves with others and desire recognition.
The difference between these two concepts shows that attention to oneself does not always mean someone ignores the interests of others.
Humans can strive to fulfill their needs while simultaneously possessing sensitivity to the suffering of others.
The event of the Banyumas residents returning their BLT can be understood through Rousseau's concept of pitié .
Their decision demonstrates consideration for the circumstances of others, even though they themselves had the opportunity to receive the aid.
They did not just think about personal needs, but also realized that there might be other community members in more difficult conditions.
The event shows that concern can influence a person's decision, even when that decision requires them to give up an opportunity to obtain something for themselves.
Psychological Perspective: Empathy and Altruistic Behavior
Beyond philosophical thought, the relationship between personal interest and social concern can also be understood through the perspective of social psychology.
Batson and Shaw (1991), in their discussion of the Empathy-Altruism Hypothesis, explain that empathy for someone in need can generate altruistic motivation.
Altruistic motivation is the drive to improve the well-being of others, rather than merely to obtain personal gain.
When someone understands the suffering experienced by others, a desire to help alleviate that difficulty can arise.
In the context of the Banyumas residents' event, the decision to return the BLT can be understood through this perspective.
Concern for other community members deemed more in need may have been one of the considerations that drove them to make that decision.
However, it is important to understand that the act of returning aid does not automatically prove a specific psychological motive. Human decisions can be influenced by various considerations, including economic circumstances, social values, and personal assessments of others' needs.
This perspective shows that the act of helping does not always have to be based on the expectation of gain. Concern for the well-being of others can also be a source of motivation.
Nevertheless, this does not mean that community members who continue to receive social assistance can be immediately labeled as selfish or lacking concern.
As long as they meet the requirements, they still have the right to receive that assistance.
Likewise, Rousseau's concept of amour-propre cannot be used simply to judge someone just because they maintain the aid they receive.
That concept is more related to how social comparison and the need for recognition can influence human behavior.
Between Personal Interest and Social Concern
When Hobbes's and Rousseau's thoughts are compared with the perspective of social psychology, it is evident that human behavior cannot be explained by a single drive.
Hobbes emphasizes the importance of personal interest and the effort to maintain life. Rousseau shows that humans also have the capacity to feel compassion for the suffering of others.
Meanwhile, Batson and Shaw provide a psychological perspective that empathy can drive the emergence of altruistic motivation.
These three perspectives help explain that personal interest and social concern are not two things that are always in conflict.
A person can fight for their life's needs without having to ignore the interests of others. Conversely, a person can also make decisions that prioritize the well-being of others even when they have personal needs.
In the issue of social assistance, what needs to be considered is not only the individual's willingness to prioritize others, but also the accuracy of the aid distribution itself.
Justice is not measured solely by an individual's willingness to return aid voluntarily. Justice must also be viewed from whether those who are truly in need have received aid according to their rights.
Moreover, not all community members have the same knowledge, access to information, or opportunities to fight for their rights.
Therefore, the distribution of social assistance should not rely solely on individual awareness. Accurate data collection systems, transparency of recipient criteria, and adequate supervision remain necessary so that aid can be distributed to the right targets.
Are Humans Truly Selfish?
Ultimately, humans cannot simply be called creatures that are entirely selfish or entirely concerned for others.
Hobbes's thought shows that humans have a drive to maintain life and fulfill their personal interests. Meanwhile, Rousseau shows that the capacity to feel compassion is also an important part of understanding human nature.
The social psychology perspective through the Empathy-Altruism Hypothesis also explains how empathy can drive someone to act for the well-being of others.
The event of the Banyumas residents returning their BLT is one illustration that the desire to fulfill personal interests does not always prevent humans from showing concern.
This action also reminds us that social life is built not only through competition to obtain things, but also through the ability to understand the needs and difficulties of others.
Thus, humans do indeed have a tendency to preserve themselves and fight for their interests. However, that does not mean that concern for others is absent within them.
Both drives can exist simultaneously and influence human actions according to the situation faced.
The main issue is not merely whether humans are inherently selfish, but how humans balance personal interests with social responsibility toward their fellow human beings.
Bibliography
Anugrah, A. (2020, 6 May). Feeling that others are more in need, 12 Banyumas residents return Corona BLT. detikNews. https://news.detik.com/read/2020/05/06/182012/5005040/1536/merasa-ada-yang-lebih-butuh-12-warga-banyumas-kembalikan-blt-corona
Batson, C. D., & Shaw, L. L. (1991). Evidence for altruism: Toward a pluralism of prosocial motives. Psychological Inquiry, 2(2), 107–122. https://doi.org/10.1207/s15327965pli0202_1
Hobbes, T. (1651). Leviathan. London. Smithsonian Libraries and Archives. https://library.si.edu/digital-library/book/leviathan00hobba
Rousseau, J.-J. (1755). Discours sur l’origine et les fondements de l’inégalité parmi les hommes. Les Classiques des sciences sociales. https://www.classiques.uqam.ca/classiques/Rousseau_jj/discours_origine_inegalite/discours_inegalite.pdf
Comments 0
Write a Comment Share your response