Why do schools with identical facilities often feel so different?
Recently, we have become familiar with the terms green flag and red flag. Originally used for relationships, these terms have now spread everywhere: to workplaces, cafes, and even campuses. Let us apply them to schools. What does a green flag school look like?
The answer is rarely about grand buildings or shiny signage. Parents entering a school for the first time often immediately sense something difficult to define: whether teachers greet them sincerely, whether students feel empowered to ask questions, or whether the atmosphere in the staff room is warm or tense. Young people call it vibes. Experts call it organizational culture.
Two schools with similar curricula, facilities, and staff sizes can feel vastly different. Peterson and Deal describe culture as an “underground river”: invisible, yet its current dictates where everyone moves. Edgar Schein adds that culture has three layers. What is visible is only the tip of the iceberg—uniforms, ceremonies, and slogans. Beneath that are values, and at the deepest level are assumptions we rarely notice.
This is where “costume malfunctions” often occur. A school may hang banners proclaiming discipline, integrity, and collaboration, but daily behavior tells a different story. Staff meetings become mere sessions for hearing decisions. Cooperation is mandated through reports rather than growing from genuine need. Performance appraisals are more concerned with counting paperwork than observing how students learn. Hargreaves calls this artificial collegiality: appearing united in photos, but empty on the inside.
Is this just about atmosphere? It turns out it is not. Research at SD Ta’miriyah Surabaya found that organizational culture explains approximately 86 percent of the variation in teacher performance (Syafira et al., 2025). A study of vocational school teachers in Pekalongan shows that school culture is the largest contributor to job satisfaction (Sutomo & Egar, 2025). Even expensive teacher training can be wasted if the school culture does not support its application in the classroom (McChesney & Cross, 2023). In short, culture is the foundation, not the decoration.
The good news is that culture can be nurtured. Not through one-off seminars, but through small, consistent actions.
First, define shared values in the form of observable behaviors. “Honesty” is not just a word on the wall, but the act of not cheating and not fabricating reports.
Second, lead by example. A principal who listens, values teachers' work, and aligns their words with their actions is more convincing than a thousand circulars.
Third, provide space for natural collaboration, such as peer classroom observation, sharing best practices, or grabbing coffee to discuss teaching.
Fourth, implement fair and clear discipline, with a spirit of guidance rather than mere punishment.
One more thing: do not rush. Culture does not change overnight, and teacher hesitation toward new things is not an enemy. It is a signal that something needs to be heard. Good change usually begins with honest conversation.
As Teacher's Day approaches, perhaps this is the right time for some light reflection. How do we welcome new teachers? How do we treat students who are not yet high achievers? How do we handle mistakes? The answers will reveal the true culture of our school.
Because in the end, banners can be put up in a day, but good vibes are only born from good habits maintained together.
References
McChesney, K., & Cross, R. (2023). School climate and culture in the implementation of teacher professional learning.
Plaku, & Leka (2025). School culture in secondary schools in Albania (incorporating the theories of Schein and Peterson & Deal).
Sutomo, & Egar (2025). Organizational culture and job satisfaction of vocational school teachers in Pekalongan Regency.
Syafira, et al. (2025). Organizational culture and teacher performance at SD Ta’miriyah Surabaya.
Comments 0
Write a Comment Share your response