JurnalPost.com - When a school shows rapid progress, there is almost always one figure who receives attention: the principal. Conversely, when a school experiences stagnation, leadership issues are often among the first to be questioned.
This is not without reason. Principals hold a strategic role in determining the direction of school development, improving the quality of learning, and building a conducive educational environment.
However, being a principal is not just about ensuring that administration runs smoothly or that all programs are executed on schedule. More than that, principals are required to be able to inspire, build cooperation, and mobilize the entire school community toward shared goals.
These challenges are becoming increasingly complex due to changes in education policy, technological developments, and the demands of implementing the Merdeka Curriculum. Principals must be able to adapt to change while ensuring that school management remains effective.
The government has updated the provisions for principal assignments through the Regulation of the Minister of Basic and Secondary Education (Permendikdasmen) Number 7 of 2025, which came into effect on 14 May 2025.
This situation raises an important question: should a principal actually be a manager or a leader?
The answer is that schools need both.
Two Important Roles in One Position
Principals perform two complementary roles: that of a manager and that of a leader.
As a manager, the principal is responsible for planning, organizing, executing, and supervising various school programs and resources. This role demands administrative capability, precision, and measured decision-making.
Meanwhile, as a leader, the principal is tasked with building a vision, providing motivation, inspiring teachers, and creating a spirit of change within the educational environment.
The difference between these two roles is evident in daily practice.
A manager ensures that learning schedules are followed, budgets are used according to regulations, and facilities and infrastructure are available. Conversely, a leader encourages teachers to continue innovating, builds a positive work culture, and fosters a shared sense of responsibility for the quality of education.
A study by Piranggada and colleagues (2025) on principal leadership in resource management shows that the quality of leadership and the effectiveness of resource management are critical components in improving school performance.
Therefore, it is not enough for a principal to only master administrative aspects. They must also be able to manage people, build communication, and create a work environment that supports the improvement of educational quality.
In general, a principal's responsibilities cover five main areas: institutional strategic planning, curriculum and learning management, human resource development, financial and facility management, and strengthening community relations.
These five areas require a blend of managerial and leadership skills so that the school can develop sustainably.
Which Leadership Style Is Most Effective?
In educational management, there are various leadership approaches that principals can apply.
One approach that is widely discussed is transformational leadership. This leadership style emphasizes the importance of a shared vision, providing motivation, empowering teachers, and developing a collaborative culture.
In the context of the Merdeka Curriculum, transformational leadership is relevant because teachers need support to develop learning that is more flexible, creative, and student-centered.
However, transformational leadership is not the only factor that determines a school's success.
Research by Silvia Annabila, Sunarni, and Juharyanto (2023) involving 119 teachers from seven junior high school 'Sekolah Penggerak' (Driving Schools) found that a principal's transformational leadership has a positive but not significant influence on teacher performance in implementing the Merdeka Curriculum.
Conversely, school culture showed a positive and significant influence on teacher performance.
These findings demonstrate that a good leadership style needs to be supported by a healthy school culture. Without a supportive work environment, the vision and motivation conveyed by the principal may not necessarily produce real change.
In addition to the transformational approach, there is instructional leadership, which focuses on improving the quality of learning through academic supervision, classroom observation, and providing feedback to teachers.
There is also distributive leadership, which emphasizes the delegation of responsibilities to vice principals, program coordinators, and teacher teams.
Meanwhile, digital leadership positions technology as a means to improve the effectiveness of school management, communication, and data-driven decision-making.
Thus, there is no single leadership style that is always the most appropriate for every school. Its effectiveness depends heavily on the organizational conditions, teacher readiness, student needs, and the challenges faced by each educational unit.
Challenges for Principals in the Field
The issue of school leadership is not only related to individual ability but also concerns the availability of principals who meet the requirements.
On 23 June 2025, the Ministry of Basic and Secondary Education recorded a need for 50,971 principals. This figure includes 40,072 unfilled principal positions and 10,899 principals projected to retire that year.
This data highlights the magnitude of the government's challenge in ensuring that every school has an adequate leader.
Beyond the issue of quantity, the quality of managerial competence is also a concern. Not all principals have the same readiness to manage resources, prepare strategic plans, or build a culture of quality.
Another challenge is the gap between planning and the implementation of school programs.
In practice, planning documents may be well-structured, but they are not necessarily followed by consistent execution. Quality improvement programs, for example, can face obstacles if they are not supported by clear supervision, evaluation, and follow-up.
On the other hand, curriculum changes also require principals to not only understand policies administratively but also be able to translate them into learning practices that suit the school's needs.
This condition shows that principals need competencies that are continuously developed, rather than just administrative experience or long tenure.
Building Higher Quality School Leadership
Efforts to strengthen school leadership need to be carried out through a system of preparation, selection, training, and continuous mentoring.
Permendikdasmen Number 7 of 2025 replaces the previous provisions in Permendikbudristek Number 40 of 2021 regarding the Assignment of Teachers as Principals.
These provisions were then supplemented by the Decree of the Minister of Basic and Secondary Education Number 129/P/2025 regarding the substantive selection of prospective principals, training, and the mechanism for assigning teachers as principals.
The government also launched the School Leadership Program on 23 June 2025 as part of efforts to improve leadership quality and meet the demand for principals.
However, improvements cannot be made solely through regulations and training. Change must also take place in school management practices.
First, principals need to build data-based planning. Student assessment results, literacy and numeracy achievements, and learning evaluations can serve as the basis for developing more targeted programs.
Second, teachers need to be involved in the decision-making process. Involving teachers not only lightens the principal's workload but also strengthens a sense of ownership and responsibility for the success of educational programs.
Third, schools must build a work culture that supports innovation, collaboration, and quality improvement. An environment that is open to new ideas will provide space for teachers to grow.
Fourth, principals need to pursue continuous competency development, whether through training, professional mentoring, or collaboration with other schools.
These steps can help principals perform managerial functions effectively while simultaneously building leadership that drives change.
Schools Need Managers and Leaders
Ultimately, the success of school management cannot be separated from the principal's ability to combine two important roles: that of a manager and a leader.
Managerial ability is needed to ensure that all school resources, programs, and administration run in an orderly and accountable manner. Meanwhile, leadership ability is required to build a vision, mobilize teachers, and create changes that impact the quality of learning.
Transformational, instructional, distributive, or digital leadership can all be relevant approaches. However, their application must consider the school culture, human resource readiness, and the actual needs of the educational unit.
The government needs to continue strengthening the system for preparing and mentoring principals. At the unit level, principals must also be bold in building data-driven management, involving teachers, and creating a work culture oriented toward quality.
This is because a quality school does not just need someone who can organize work, but also a figure who can mobilize the people within it.
Good principals are those who understand when to act as a manager to ensure everything runs in an orderly fashion, and when to be a leader who inspires change.
Comments 0
Write a Comment Share your response